Web Design Index 5
Product Description
Web Design Indexes are international bestsellers, with about a quarter million copies sold worldwide. Since its first edition in the year 2000, the annual Web Design Index has developed into one of the most important publications in its field. Year after year, it gives an accurate overview of the state of the art in web design. Every Web Design Index contains 1002 outstanding web pages. With each web page, the URL is indicated, as well as the names of those involved in the design and programming. Selection for the Web Design Index is based on design quality, innovation, and effectiveness, and the books offer examples of all conceivable forms and styles.
At the time i need a book of just different site design. And this was the one is was very Inspirational in helping get starting with sketches and layout just to get a fill for different concepts for sites.
Rating: 4 / 5
The color screen shots are great and I’ve been able to use this book to get some ideas and inspiration for sites I’ve built. That being said, here’s my beef:
1) Why organize by color scheme? There have been lots of complaints that these books come with little explanation as to why the chosen sites were selected. An easy way to remedy this would be to organize chapters in such a way that focuses on key aspects: navigation, layout, use of graphics/photos, color schemes, interactivity, etc.
2) The disk that came with it doesn’t work much of the time, and none of the Flash sites worked.
3) For sites that have dynamic elements, like rollovers, etc., it would have been nice had they shown an example of the behavior in the screen shot.
4) The websites featured weren’t that great. Hey, everyone has his/her own taste, but when I got it (which was before Index 6 came out), it didn’t represent some of the more interesting things happening in web design (in my opinion).
5) The pages are thick and due to its shape, the book won’t stay open to a page and is kind of a pain to handle. This may seem silly, but it was an irritant for me with a desk full of papers.
In using this book, I often found myself endlessly flipping through pages, flagging certain ones with coded post-its, reading “nav” or “photos.” Because of this impracticality, I mostly ended up going back to the growing number of websites devoted to collecting and presenting (with screenshots!) contemporary, well-styled websites. These frequently include discussions of certain trends, like color choice, web logos, layout configurations, etc.
This book is nice to have around, in spite of its problems. Its limitations may be a good thing, in that it forces you to narrow your likes and dislikes within a limited collection of ideas. The Internet, in its infinitude, can be paralyzing. This helps you step back for a second and just consider the visual elements of a home page.
I have not looked at Index 6, but its likely to repeat some of what I think are errors. One that’s inherent: very soon these books become outdated. I’m not sure they’re useful enough to keep buying them.
Rating: 3 / 5
Sometimes you need a book that has nothing but art in order to be inspired.
By looking at this book I can see the many ways that my sites can be formatted and changed…as well as see new ways for me to display my sites…it is an A+++++
Too much review shows an arrogance that all other artwork is under you..this shows that all art is different and catered to many different types of people…its the web folks
Rating: 5 / 5
A large listing of 1002 websites that the publishers deem to be the best designed for 2004. A page of each site is shown. Typically, it is often the home page. While the book’s CD shows these as actual webpages, so that you can best appreciate them in their intrinsic environment, instead of the printed page.
Commendably, the book covers websites from all over the globe. But the drawback is that there is no commentary on what distinguishes a site. Broad scope of content, but little depth. The book might be far improved if the authors had also offered some analysis.
Rating: 3 / 5